Neurobiological correlates of panic disorder and agoraphobia.
MK Al-Haddad, RP Sequeira, U Nayar
Department of Psychiatry, Salmaniya Hospital, Bahrain., Bahrain
M K Al-Haddad
Department of Psychiatry, Salmaniya Hospital, Bahrain.
Panic Disorder and agoraphobia offer considerable diagnostic and management challenges, particularly in general practice. We describe a typical case of panic disorder in a young adult. The recent advances in our understanding of brain functions can be used to explain to a certain extent the biologic basis of panic disorder. A hypothetical model integrating current views on panic disorder and agoraphobia has been proposed. The management principles including the role of cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy have been discussed.
|How to cite this article:|
Al-Haddad M K, Sequeira R P, Nayar U. Neurobiological correlates of panic disorder and agoraphobia. J Postgrad Med 2001;47:55-61
|How to cite this URL:|
Al-Haddad M K, Sequeira R P, Nayar U. Neurobiological correlates of panic disorder and agoraphobia. J Postgrad Med [serial online] 2001 [cited 2022 Sep 30 ];47:55-61
Available from: https://www.jpgmonline.com/text.asp?2001/47/1/55/231
Since the time of the ancient Greeks, there have been consistent reports of a disorder causing the most irrational fear in otherwise sane people. In the 6th century BC the Greek poetess Sappho gave a clear description of the symptoms of panic: dry mouth, a sense of burning under the skin, a sense of being about to die, tinnitus, blurred vision and sweating. It was not until the later part of the nineteenth century that this came to be known as “agoraphobia”, which literally translates “fear of the market place”. More recently the term is used to mean fear of public places or open spaces. While such fears characterise the majority of agoraphobics, recent evidences suggest that these situational fears are not the primary fears in agoraphobia. It is the fear of panic attacks regardless of where they occur that is the primary fear in panic disorder and agoraphobia. When panic attacks are very frequent or when a person spends a considerable amount of time fearfully anticipating the next attack of panic, that individual is said to suffer from panic disorder.
The DSM – IV classification defines a panic attack as a discrete period of intense fear or discomfort, with four or more of the following symptoms:
* Palpitation, pounding /accelerated heart rate.
* Feeling of choking
* Sensation of shortness of breath/smothering
* Chest pain/discomfort
* Chills/hot flushes
* Nausea/abdominal distress
* Feeling dizzy, unsteady, lightheaded, faint
* Fear of losing control / going crazy
* Fear of dying
These symptoms develop abruptly, and reach a peak within 10 minutes. As defined by the American Psychiatry Association an individual has “panic disorder” if:
* he or she has recurrent unexpected panic attacks.
* at least one of the attacks has been followed by a month or more of persistent concern about having additional attacks.
* the attacks are not due to the direct effects of a substance or general medical condition, nor they are better accounted for by another mental disorder.
* The DSM – IV implies a temporal relationship between panic attacks and agoraphobic avoidance. A diagnosis of panic disorder is typically given as occurring with, or without agoraphobia.
Agoraphobia is defined as “anxiety about being in places or situations from which escape might be difficult (or embarrassing) or in which help may not be available in the event of having an unexpected or situationally predisposed panic attack or panic like symptoms”. Characteristically situations that are avoided include traveling alone, being outside home alone, in a tunnel or open spaces.
In contrast to the DSM – IV, the ICD – 10 does not imply a primacy of panic attacks in its nosologic structure. Agoraphobia is listed under phobic anxiety disorders and is defined behaviorally by an “interrelated and often overlapping cluster of phobias embracing fears of leaving home, of entering shops, crowds and public places, or of traveling alone in trains, buses or planes”.
Empirical studies favour the DSM – IV more than the ICD-10. Panic disorder patients typically have panic attacks before agoraphobia. In terms of clinical practice it is very rare to see an individual with longstanding panic disorder without situation avoidance.
The following case illustrates the salient clinical features of panic disorder:
A 29-year-old male came to the psychiatric clinic after watching a programme on the local TV addressing panic disorder. For the past two years, he has undergone different medical investigations and consultations, including one with a cardiologist because of his belief that he has a heart problem.
Two years ago, while he was presiding a stormy meeting of his company’s board, he felt dramatic increase in his heart rate, his breathing became difficult, he felt tingling sensations in the fingers of the left hand with trembling. He also developed intense stabbing pains in the chest, profuse sweating and muscle stiffness. He felt that he might be having a heart attack. He was rushed to the emergency department where an ECG was recorded and serum cardiac enzymes were tested. No abnormality was detected and he was soon released after an i.v. injection of 10mg diazepam. He was advised to check with his general practitioner (GP) later on.
Since that time, he developed a pattern of having palpitations, difficulty in breathing and sweating at least 1-2 times/week; he becomes frightened that this might be a heart attack and he would rush to the emergency department seeking medical help.
Following his first attack he would never go on his own to any place where medical help could not be quickly obtained. In fact he limited traveling in his car alone to a radius of 3-4 km only around the emergency department in order to reach help in case he develops a heart attack.
He started to avoid closed places like cinemas and shopping malls anticipating that his escape route might be blocked; he gave up altogether his hobby of fishing in his boat because it would be too far and too late to seek medical help.
Born and raised in a small city, he left school to attend college in USA to study Business Administration. He is the youngest of four children, with an older brother and two sisters. Both parents are alive and well; mother was described as overprotective and a worrier. None of his direct family members had contact with psychiatric services.
After finishing his studies he worked for four year with his father who is a businessman. Later, he established his own company and managed it successfully for nearly three years. He is not married and remained with his parents at home. He does not smoke or drink, he does not have a girl friend or a current emotional attachment.
His GP did a routine physical check-up, full blood count and thyroid function tests and detected no abnormalities. He was advised to cut down daily consumption of Turkish coffee. He treated him with diazepam 5mg tid. The cardiologist started him on propranolol 40mg tid. His symptoms were relieved but still recurred once or twice a month.
Before a diagnosis of panic disorder is established one must exclude other causes of anxiety e.g. hyperthyroidism, Cushing’s syndrome, phaeochromocytoma, hypoglycemia, vestibular disturbances and mitral valve prolapse syndrome. Differentiation from other psychopathologic conditions can at times be problematic and include many anxiety disorders such as social phobia (panic is consequence of fear of scrutiny by others, or negative evaluation), separation anxiety (mainly in children), claustrophobia (being in an enclosed space and unable to get out causes the person to panic), while in agoraphobia the individual fears he might have a panic attack in an enclosed space because of inability to get out easily.
This case illustrates three observations common to panic disorder and agoraphobia. First, the disorder had a clear onset, which the patient has dated back to his first attack of panic. Second, the avoidance of situations developed subsequent to the panic attack for the fear of the consequence of having a heart attack. The panic attack involved a dramatic increase in sympathetic arousal, the origin of which is not clear to the patient and subsequently misinterpreted as a sign of a heart attack.
Most phobias emerge in childhood and early adolescence except for agoraphobia and claustrophobia, which emerge after adolescence. It was initially hoped that there is a unique predisposition to panic attacks. The genetic studies implied a heritable component to panic attacks., However, it was explained that the hereditary predisposition was a general trait of anxiety proneness rather than being specific to panic disorder or agoraphobia., Another explanation to increased vulnerability implied that the flight or fight response is more easily triggered. This response may be triggered under potentially dangerous circumstances (true alarm), or it may be triggered in the absence of potential danger in response to a negative perception of stress (false alarm). When symptoms overlap between patients with panic disorder, overlap was more obvious among those with panic and generalized anxiety disorder.
In spite of the fact that an anxiety response is more easily triggered in a person with anxiety proneness, there has been no clear evidence of a biological substance causing panic disorder. Hence more attention was directed to the factors that predispose an individual with anxiety traits towards developing panic disorder and agoraphobia. Hyperventilation was one of the factors exclusively scrutinized in order to find out whether it can cause or exacerbate a panic attack. In addition, cognitive process has been extensively studied.
The symptoms of hyperventilation syndrome were found to be very close to those of panic attacks. This has consequently lead to the assumption that hyperventilation can be blamed for the triggering of panic attacks or at least contribute to their exacerbation in susceptible individuals. The support for this hypothesis is the finding that patients with panic attacks recognize the symptoms produced by voluntary hyperventilation as similar to the symptoms of panic., However, other findings were not consistent with the hypothesis: while panic attacks induced by lactate infusion were associated with hyperventilation, voluntary hyperventilation did not produce a clear panic attack. Furthermore, no difference was found between the symptoms of panic attacks with or without hyperventilation. This leads to the conclusion that although hyperventilation can produce symptoms similar to panic attacks, it is not the cause. The obvious question that naturally follows is how do the symptoms produced by hyperventilation relate to the experience of panic attacks?
Various experimental models have been used in exploring the neural substrate and neurotransmitters involved in panic disorder. The patient seems to experience a crescendo of autonomic symptoms and then fears of impending death. Based on accumulated experimental evidence the irritable foci in the brain stem, especially the pons (locus coeruleus) and medulla (chemoreceptors), serve as the source of panic with characteristic hyperventilation and cardiovascular changes. It has been proposed that patients with panic disorder inherit brainstem loci that are hyperexcitable, and that aberrant neural transmission excites these loci.
Limbic lobe is believed to be the centre for many basic emotions such as rage, arousal and fear. Inhibition of the hippocampal activity by locus coeruleus provokes generalized forms of anxiety., It is interesting to note that although benzodiazepines such as diazepam have little effect on acute panic attacks, they are effective in blunting anticipatory anxiety. Moreover, diazepam markedly reduces generalized anxiety in patients with panic disorder but does not prevent lactate-induced actual panic. Thus the neuroanatomic hypothesis of Gorman et al can be used to explain why benzodiazepines are effective in treating anticipatory anxiety but not the panic attacks.
Asymmetry in blood flow through specific limbic structures, especially cholecystokinin (CCK-4) induced changes in regional cerebral blood flow. during panic attacks has been extensively investigated. The temporal dynamics of CCK-4 induced changes in blood flow suggests activation of brainstem-hypothalamic region leading to claustrum-insular activation. In addition, studies on cerebral metabolic activity by positron emission tomography scan in panic disorder have shown aberrant metabolism in hippocampal and parahippocampal regions. Whether this abnormality represents altered blood flow, a change in neuronal activity or output from these areas is uncertain.
The hippocampal formation with its connections to the amygdala may also play a role in contextual conditioning. This form of conditioning to a “place” or “situation” in which external stimuli become associated with fearful behaviour is relevant in panic disorder and agoraphobia. An integrated neurobiological model in which fear and anxiety act as a backdrop for explaining panic has been suggested: the structures and pathways involved in transmission of sensory data to signal processing areas in the cortices, limbic areas (amygdala, hippocampus), and brain-stem structures (periaqueductal grey area, locus coeruleus) are included in this integrated model.
Once a threat or fearful stimulus is assessed through a process of integrating past and present experiences, the processing areas (orbitofrontal cortex, amygdala) formulate and elicit a fear or anxiety response. Key structures that execute the response include the locus coeruleus (triggering autonomic and neuroendocrine responses via the hypothalamus and nucleus paragigantocellularis), the hypothalamus (autonomic and neuroendocrine components of fear response), dorsal nucleus of the vagus (parasympathetic activation), parabrachial nucleus (fear-induced hyperventilation), trigeminal nucleus and facial motor nucleus (facial expression of fear), and striatum and periaqueductal grey area (fear induced motor activation for fight or flight responses).,
Currently available experimental evidence explaining the neurobiological basis of panic disorder, including the neuroanatomic pathways with their connections are summarized in [Figure:1]. The major neurotransmitter involved in some of these loci – norepinephrine in locus coeruleus, 5-hydroxytryptamine (5HT) in raphe nuclei, and gama aminobutyric acid (GABA) in the hippocampus – can be correlated with therapeutic response to drugs such as central sympatholytics (clonidine), serotonin selective reuptake inhibitors (SSRI) and benzodiazepines, respectively., While the proposed hypothetical model is an oversimplification, it helps in formulating a convergent view of the clinical features of panic disorder derived from advances in neurobiology.
Various cognitive models have explained ways in which the cognitive processes can contribute to the production of panic attacks. [Figure:1] emphasizes the catastrophic misinterpretation placed upon internal bodily cues in some individuals with anxiety sensitivity. Fear of these internal sensations may form a crucial maintaining factor in panic disorders: when these sensations are experienced they can elicit panic reactions since the feared interceptions are usually associated with anxiety, one may expect the panic reaction to exemplify the feared situations. The panic attack can thus be conceptualised as a positive feedback loop, the panic disorder as a fear or phobophobia. Anxiety traits may predispose individuals to “false alarms” but anxiety sensitivity may encourage an individual to worry about the sensations. In other words the development of panic attack is not the experience of somatic sensation, but the interpretation placed upon those sensations. In support of this notion it was found that agoraphobics interpret ambiguous scenarios in a more threatening manner than normal subjects. In addition there is bias towards threat-related information leading to superior recall of phobic material when compared with normal subjects.
Panic disorder and agoraphobia are currently conceptualized as two separate, but frequently related, disorders. Panic attacks are in a way the motor that drives the agoraphobic avoidance. Therefore, it is expected that effective treatment of agoraphobia requires effective management of panic attacks. The first goal of an effective treatment for agoraphobia (with panic disorder) is to stop the panic attacks and their effect on the patient’s life. The second goal is to reduce any concurrent agoraphobic avoidance which usually involves anticipatory anxiety and anxiety triggered upon exposure. In short, effective treatment of panic disorder and agoraphobia should be based on three elements namely control of panic attacks, the cessation of fear-driven avoidance and the reduction of the vulnerability.
The first method used for treatment is cognitive therapy which is based on the cognitive theory of panic. Typically cognitive therapy is focused on eliminating the catastrophic interpretation of the panic symptoms. Various techniques are used to help patients identify, then change the misinterpretations of their bodily sensations. Cognitive procedures include identification and challenge of the patient’s evidence for his / her misinterpretations, and replacing them with the realistic ones. This includes induction of panicky sensations by hyperventilating the patient in order to demonstrate possible causes of the patient’s symptoms. A home work assignment is given in which the patient keeps daily record of negative thoughts and irrational responses. Applied relaxation devised by Ost, is a behavioural approach used for teaching patients to identify early signs of panic and later on controlling them through relaxation techniques.
Several classes of drugs have been used with variable degree of success in the management of panic disorder and agoraphobia: antidepressants including the tricyclic drugs, serotonin selective re-uptake inhibitors (SSRI) and monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOI), as well as antianxiety drugs like benzodiazepines. Benzodiazepines have a rapid onset of effect and are effective in blocking anticipatory anxiety as well as panic attacks. The main limitations of benzodiazepines such as alprazolam, clonazepam and diazepam, is their ability to cause excessive sedation, drug-dependence, memory problems, falls in the elderly and occasionally, paradoxical rage. A gradual tapering of the dosage is required to minimize the severity of withdrawal symptoms.,
Among antidepressant drugs the efficacy and safety of the tricyclic drugs such as imipramine and clo-imipramine has been best documented. The need to start therapy with low dose and gradually titrate the dosage upwards is important to minimize the sedation and autonomic adverse effects, and to improve patient compliance. High drop-out rate due to adverse effects is well known., Treatment with tricyclics is accompanied with significant improvements in anxiety severity, dysphoric mood and functional wellbeing. Imipramine has been suggested as a clinically relevant reference with which effectiveness of alternative drugs should be compared.
Concurrent use of benzodiazepines and psychotherapy for panic disorder is a prevalent but highly controversial practice. Cognitive behavior therapy has been combined with pharmacotherapy in the treatment of panic disorders in three ways: (a) to treat agoraphobic symptoms in the condition of panic with agoraphobia; (b) to reduce withdrawal effects during drug-taper, and (c) to treat panic attacks. Efforts to educate and counsel patients in the clinical setting regarding the psychopathology of panic attacks may improve the outcome of pharmacotherapy. Since the cognitive behaviour therapy involves usually several sessions, it is not widely offered to patients because of cost considerations. Although there are many rationales for combining pharmacotherapy with psychotherapy approach, critics contend that benzodiazepines foster drug abuse and dependence and undermine psychosocial treatment. However, pre-existing pharmacotherapy with either antianxiety or antidepressant drugs did not either enhance or detract the long-term outcome of brief intensive group cognitive behaviour therapy in patients with panic disorder with or without agoraphobia.
Since panic disorder with or without agoraphobia is a prevalent condition which presents primarily in general practice, a recent study looked into the effectiveness of fluvoxamine or cognitive behaviour therapy either alone or in combination, in a general practice setting. All modalities of therapy showed a satisfactorily significant advantage over placebo as regard to a range of outcome ratings. Interestingly the group employing cognitive behaviour therapy showed the most robust and consistent response.
Although improvement during treatment is well documented in patients with panic disorder and agoraphobia, a recent study has confirmed lasting improvement years after exposure treatment, though some residual symptoms were the norm.
The availability of SSRI such as fluoxetine, fluvoxamine and setraline has shifted the emphasis from tricyclics in the treatment of panic disorder. These drugs are better tolerated by patients and the drop-out rates are generally low. In two multicentric trials., the efficacy and safety of sertraline was confirmed. Further data supporting the clinical preference for SSRI are emerging.
In clinical settings, the administration of a benzodiazepine with a tricyclic has also been proposed to reduce the frequency and severity of adverse effects in the treatment of panic disorder. Usually these patients may require a dose of imipramine in excess of 125 mg/day, a dose at which significant adverse effects are expected to occur. Combination of imipramine with lorazepam showed that in almost three fourth of these patients the panic attacks disappeared and were free from phobic attacks. Such combined treatment allowed the use of low doses of drugs, reduced the frequency and severity of the adverse effects and improved patient compliance.
The MAOI are believed by some clinicians to be most potent anti-panic agent, but their considerable adverse effects limit their use. The availability of selective MAOI offers a new avenue in evaluating their potential in treating panic disorder.
The beta adrenoceptor blocking agent propranolol is mainly useful for ameliorating the autonomic-sympathetic component of a panic attack, particularly the palpitations and tremors. In addition, to what extent the central effects of propranolol contribute towards the clinical benefit is uncertain.
Based on the data drawn from the Cross-National Collaborative Panic Study, over 70% of the patients used primary care for mental health services, whereas about 47% of the patients used specialty mental health services. Nearly half of the patients saw a non- psychiatrist medical specialist, most often a cardiologist. The mean estimated expenditure for the panic episode was $ 3339, about half of which was accounted for by specialty mental health expenditures. Both primary care and specialty mental health sectors play prominent roles in the community treatment of panic disorder.
During the past decades substantial progress has been achieved in our understanding of panic disorder and agoraphobia. A case of panic disorder with agoraphobia described in this paper illustrates the typical course of events likely to occur in a general practices setting. We have reviewed some recent advances in neurobiology of panic disorder and agoraphobia and have proposed a hypothetical model which helps in formulating a convergent view of the clinical features of panic disorder and agoraphobia. The various modalities of treatment incorporating cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy have been discussed.
American Psychiatric Association. DSM – IV: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th edition. Washington DC: American Psychiatric Association, 1994.|
|2||World Health Organization. International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10); Geneva: WHO,1991.|
|3||Aronson TA, Logue CM. On the longitudinal course of panic disorder: development history and predictors of phobic complications. Compr Psychiatry 1987; 28:344-55.|
|4||Franklin JA. The changing nature of agoraphobic fears. Brit J Clin Psychol 1987; 26:127-33.|
|5||Ost L.G. Age of onset in different phobias. J Abnormal Psychol 1987; 6:223-9.|
|6||Crowe RR. The genetics of panic disorder and agoraphobia. Psychiatric Developments 1985; 2:243-8.|
|7||Crowe RR, Noyes R, Pauls DL, Symen D. A family study of panic disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1983; 40:1065-9.|
|8||Roth M. Agoraphobia, panic disorder and generalised anxiety disorder: some implications of recent advances. Psychiatric Developments 1984; 2:31-52.|
|9||Andrews G. Classification of neurotic disorders. J Roy Soc Med 1990; 83:606-7.|
|10||Telch MJ, Brouillard M, Telch CF, Agras WF, Taylor CB. Role of cognitive appraisal in panic related avoidance. Behav Res Ther 1989; 27:273-83.|
|11||Magarian GJ. Hyperventilation syndrome: Infrequently recognised common expressions of anxiety and stress. Medicine 1982; 61:219-36.|
|12||Garssen B, De Reuiter C, Van Dyke R. Breathing retraining: a rational placebo? Clin Psychol Rev 1992; 12:141-53.|
|13||Gorman JM, Askanasi J, Liebowitz MR, Fyer AJ, Stein J, Kinney JM, et al. Response to hyperventilation in a group of patients with panic disorder. Am J of Psychiatry 1984; 141:857-61.|
|14||Hibbert GA, Pilsbury D. Hyperventilation in panic attacks: Ambulant monitoring of transcutaneous carbon dioxide. Brit J Psychiatry 1989; 155:805-9.|
|15||Gorman JM, Liebowitz MR, Fyer AJ, Stein J. A neuroanatomical hypothesis for panic disorder. Am J Psychiatry 1989; 146:148-61. |
|16||Torgersen S: Genetic factors in anxiety disorders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1983; 40:1085-89.|
|17||Penfield W. Functional localization in temporal and deep Sylvian areas. Res Publ Assoc Res Nerv Ment Dis 1958; 36:21-26.|
|18||Gray JA, Holt L, McNaughton N. In: Costa E, Ed. Clinical Implications of the Experimental Pharmacology of the Benzodiazepines: From Molecular Biology to Clinical Practice. New York, Raven Press 1983.|
|19||Muskin PR, Fyer AJ. The treatment of panic disorder. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1981; 1:81-90.|
|20||Javenmard M, Shlik J, Kennedy SH, Vaccarino FJ, Houle S., Bradwejn J. Neuroanatomic correlate of CCK-4 induced panic attacks in healthy humans: A comparison of two time points. Biol Psychiatry 1999; 45:872-82.|
|21||Charney DS, Heninger GR, Breier A. Noradrenergic function in panic anxiety: effects of yohimbine in healthy subjects and patients with agoraphobia and panic disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1984; 41:751-63.|
|22||Bisaga A, Katz JL, Antonini A, Wright E, Margouleff C, Gorman JM, et al. Cerebral glucose metabolism in women with panic disorder. Am J Psychiatry 1998; 155:1178-83.|
|23||Stein L, Wise CD, Berger BD. Antianxiety action of benzodiazepines decrease in activity of serotonin neurons in the punishment system. In: S. Garattini, Mussini E, Randal LO, Eds., The Benzodiazepines. . New York, Raven Press, 1973.|
|24||Pickel VM, Joh TH, Reiss DJ. Immunocytochemical Evidence for serotoninergic innervatory of noradrenergic neurons in nucleus locus coeruleus. In: S. Garattini, Pujal JF, Samanin R Eds., Interactions Between Putative Neurotransmitters in the Brain. New York, Raven Press, 1978.|
|25||Goddard AW, Charney DS. Towards an integrated neurobiology of panic disorder. J Clin Psychiatry 1997; 58:4-11.|
|26||Kelly D, Mitchell-Heggs N, Shean D. Anxiety and the effects of sodium lactate assessed clinically and physiologically. Br J Psychiatry 1971; 119:129-41.|
|27||Woods SW, Charney DS, Lake J. Carbon dioxide sensitivity in panic anxiety: Ventilatory and anxiogenic response to carbon dioxide in healthy subjects and patients with panic anxiety before and after alprazolam treatment. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1986; 43:900-9.|
|28||Malizia AL, Cunningham VJ, Bell CJ, Liddle PF, Jones T, Nutt DJ, et al. Decreased brain GABA benzodiazepine receptor binding in panic disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1998; 55:715-20.|
|29||Jenek F, Moreau J, Brendsen HHG, Boes M, Broekkamp CLE, Martin JR, et al. Anti-aversive effects of 5HT2C receptor agonists and fluoxetine in a model of panic like anxiety in rats. Eur Neuropsychopharmacol. 1998; 8:161-8.|
|30||Clark DM. A cognitive approach to panic. Behav Res Ther 1986; 24:461-70.|
|31||McNally RJ, Foa EB. Cognition and agoraphobia bias in the interpretation of threat. Cogn Ther Res 1987; 11:567-82.|
|32||Mathews A, Mogg K, May J, Eysenk MJ. Implicit and explicit memory bias in anxiety. J Abnorm Psychol 1989; 8:193-4.|
|33||Mathews AM, MacLeod C. Discrimination of threat cues without awareness in anxiety states. J Abnorm Psychol 1986, pp 131-8.|
|34||Salkovskis, PM and Clark DM. Cognitive therapy for panic disorder. J Cog Psychotherapy 1991; 5:215-26.|
|35||Öst, LG. Applied relaxation: description of a coping technique and review of controlled studies. Behav Res Therapy 1987; 25:397-410.|
|36||Marchesi C, Ampollini P, Signifredi R, Maggini C. The treatment of panic disorder in a clinical setting: a 12 month naturalistic study. Neuropsychobiology 1997; 36:25-31.|
|37||Rosenbaum JF, Moroz G, Bowden CL. Clonazepam Panic Disorder Dose- Response Study Group. Clonazepam in the treatment of panic disorder with or without agoraphobia: a dose-response study of efficacy, safety, and discontinuance.. J Clin Psychiopharmacol 1997; 17:390-400.|
|38||Papp LA, Schneier FR, Fyer AJ, Leibowitz MR, Gorman JM, Coplan JD, et al. Clomipramine treatment of panic disorder: pros and cons. J Clin Psychiatry 1997; 58:423-25.|
|39||Mavissakalian MR, Perel JM, Talbott-Green M, Sloan C. Gauging the effectiveness of extended imipramine treatment for panic disorder with agoraphobia. Biol Psychiatry 1998; 43:48-54.|
|40||Gelder MG. Combined pharmacotherapy and cognitive behaviour therapy in the treatment of panic disorder. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1998; 18(Suppl 2):25-55.|
|41||Spiegel DA, Bruce TJ. Benzodiazepines and exposure-based cognitive behaviour therapies for panic disorder: conclusions from combined trials. Am J Psychiatry 1997; 154:773-81.|
|42||Oei TP, Llamas M, Evans L. Does Chronic drug intake affect the long term outcome of group cognitive behaviour therapy in panic disorder with or without agoraphobia? Behav Res Ther 1997; 35:851-7.|
|43||Sharp DM, Power KG, Simpson RJ, Swaison V, Anstee JA. Global measures of outcome in a controlled comparison of pharmacological and psychological treatment of panic disorder and agoraphobia in primary care. Br J Gen Pract 1997; 47:150-5.|
|44||Kilic C, Noshiravani H, Basoglu M, Marks I. Agoraphabia and panic disorder: 3.5 years after alprazolam and or exposure treatment. Psychother Psychosom 1997; 66:175-8.|
|45||Pohl RB, Wolkow RM, Clary CM. Sertraline in the treatment of panic disorder: a double blind multicentre trial. Am J Psychiatry 1998; 155:1189-95.|
|46||Pollack MH, Otto MW, Worthington JJ, Manfro GC, Wolkow R. Sertraline in the treatment of panic disorder: a flexible dose multicentric trial. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1998; 55:1010-6.|
|47||Jefferson JW, Antidepressants in panic disorder. J Clin Psychiatry 1997; (Suppl 2):20-4 and 24-5. |
|48||Leon AC, Olfson M, Portera L. Service utilization and expenditures for the treatment of panic disorder. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 1997; 19:82-8.